“Kiss Your Ash Good Bye”

“Kiss Your Ash Good Bye”

Spread the love

That’s what the Massachusetts state forester told me – the emerald ash borer is on the loose in southern Berkshire County where my wife and I have our 130-acre woodlot and within the next couple of years this pest is expected to kill virtually all the native ashes, or roughly 5% of the forest trees, in this region. In fact, this mortality is expected to become general throughout Connecticut, too, and eventually throughout southern New England and beyond. And to my mind, it is a good argument for the creation of GMO plants.

Ash infested with borers (Daniel Herms, The Ohio State University, Bugwood.org)

This loss of trees to an introduced Asian pest is even more grievous in context. My region lost all its American chestnut trees (as much as 1/4th of the hardwood trees) to the ravages of an introduced Asian virus in the early part of the 20th century. More recently, it lost most of its hemlocks (an estimated 6% of the forest trees) to an introduced Asian insect pest. If the Asian Longhorn Beetle ever escapes from its limited urban outbreaks into the forest in general, 73% of the forest trees in southern New England would be at risk.

Asian ashes, chestnuts, and other trees which evolved alongside the Asian pests have a natural resistance. American scientists have tried to interbreed these Asian trees with their American relatives to transfer the resistance but given the long time it takes a tree to grow from seed to sexual maturity, progress has been painfully slow.  A 35-year effort by the American Chestnut Foundation to breed a resistant American chestnut, for example, has only begun to produce significant results in the last few years.

Genetic engineering offers a far more efficient way to insert genes for pest resistance into the DNA of American trees. This has already been accomplished with American chestnut trees and Dr. Paula M Pijut, a research plant physiologist with the U.S. Forest Service, has been working on something similar for several species of North American ash trees in her laboratory at Purdue University. Both of these projects have been accomplished in a time scale of years rather than decades. An additional advantage of genetic engineering is that it is possible to produce resistant trees that differ from their American ancestors by only a handful of genes rather than the compromise Asian-American hybrids produced by conventional breeding techniques.

I’m no fan of GMO food, but GMO trees seem to me a far better alternative than a biologically impoverished forest.

Posted by

Thomas Christopher
on January 18, 2015 at 11:05 am, in the category Science Says.

15 Comments
    • kermit
    • 3rd March 2016

    Yes. Like any technology, GMO is evil only in inappropriate applications. When unregulated and applied for the short-term profit of a particular company (I’m looking at you, Monsanto) it will not have our common interests at heart, let alone nature in general. Having introduced the pests, there are no natural and satisfactory responses, only best of several imperfect choices. GMO focused on resistance to an introduced pest sounds just right. It’s what nature would do, after all, given 1000 years of the current situation.

    • Tibs
    • 30th May 2016

    Sorry those nasty little bastards have reached New England. Caused lots of damage in the Great Lakes states. Think they came into a Michigan port. I wonder, have any Western Hemisphere pests been accidentally sent east?

    • kermit
    • 18th October 2016

    I know that the black squirrel (a grey squirrel mutant) in the UK and the raccoon in Northern Europe and Japan are introduced from North America. I imagine that both are at least a low-level pest.

    • Thomas Christopher
    • 7th November 2016

    Actually, I just heard a lecture about how an American fungal disease is killing all the red pines in Japan. I think that because the Asian flora is bigger and more diverse, it tends to have more pests and we suffer more on this end.

    • Liz
    • 13th November 2016

    I dislike how people turn against GMO’s. It is a technology not a product. Like any technology it can be used for good and bad things. Too often I see people lumping all GMO products together with an air of hatred, leaving no room for situations like this were the technology could be used for very good things.

    • Tami
    • 14th November 2016

    Good morning from central Indiana, where all the mature ash trees are dead or dying. One thing I’ve noticed as they die, however, is that under that stress, they produce tons of seeds. So I encounter ash seedlings all over the place. Perhaps you should begin gathering seeds from prime specimens around your acreage and find a seedbank to store them for you. It’s not answer to the problem you face but it could contribute to the solution you propose.

    • Linnea Borealis
    • 14th November 2016

    It’s hard to argue against GMO as an unnatural approach, when we’re expecting our forests to withstand unnatural threats. I fully agree with kermit in that any technology could put to use for good – or bad.

    • Vicky Shallow
    • 15th November 2016

    As info
    Emerald ash borer is a phloem feeder and is therefore possibly good food for woodpeckers especially yellow-bellied sapsuckers. As soon as they are recognized as food, the problem may go away. GMO may not.

    • Thomas Christopher
    • 15th November 2016

    I don’t think that woodpeckers on their own can stop the ravages of Emerald Ash Borer. But maybe in combination with some other biological controls carefully selected from the borer’s insect predators in its homeland, the birds could moderate the damage. The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station found a tiny predacious beetle that feeds on woolly adelgids and is saving hemlocks in that state.

    • Anna
    • 15th November 2016

    I agree with Vicky about woodpeckers. There has been a study done that showed healthy populations of woodpeckers having a dramatic effect on EAB populations. As stated, woodpeckers may not save one tree but they could potentially save a forest. The birds themselves are fast to catch on- and more abundant food means more woodpeckers and the cycle sort of works. In areas where woodpeckers aren’t abundant but ash trees are (like in the middle of urban landscapes), I imagine woodpeckers won’t have as much of an effect. Maybe Ash won’t be a go-to urban landscape tree for a while?

    • Vicky Shallow
    • 15th November 2016

    Thank you Anna.
    Do you collect seed from that butternut? And where do you live?
    Vicky

    • Thomas Christopher
    • 15th November 2016

    Do you have a link for that study about woodpeckers? I’d love to read it.

    • HeatherColleen
    • 15th November 2016

    Here are a handful of links:https://etd.ohiolink.edu/ap/10?0::NO:10:P10_ACCESSION_NUM:toledo1279242304http://www.nbb.cornell.edu/wkoenig/K179TA_13.pdfhttp://news.uic.edu/emerald-ash-borer-problem-solvedhttp://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0378112713007858

    • Denise R
    • 15th November 2016

    Using genetic engineering to create trees resistant to the emerald ash borer is a very bad idea. One of the unintended consequences of breeding pest resistance into plants has been the creation of so-called superbugs. It only takes a few survivors to pass on resistance to whatever has been inserted to the ash’s genes to create a line of borers that will be even more difficult to eradicate.

    • Erika T
    • 15th November 2016

    So many lovely trees that we have lost Elms, Chestnuts now our Ashes! Interesting idea about GMO trees.. If it can help us stop losing out lovely trees, and who eats GMO trees, except birds, bugs etc.. Hmm
    ~Erika

Leave a comment

Recent Posts

They asked for it!

A few weeks ago, the Ranters were asked by Time.com’s Money publication to supply a list of good and bad ways to spend money in the garden. I’ll be honest; I usually ...

Read More

The Landscapes of McMansion Hell

For making me laugh while I learn, I LOVE the architecture critic Kate Wagner and her highly opinionated blog McMansion Hell. Who could resist her “Pringles Can of Shame ™” award in ...

Read More